Title - The Evolution of Planetary Surfaces
In the Race to Mars, we saw how the mission crew was affected by the red dust that covers the surface of Mars. This educational resource provides teachers with background information, teaching notes and a hands-on simulation to help students gain insight into the processes of erosion that result in the evolution of planetary surfaces.

Curriculum Outcomes

(From the Pan-Canadian Protocol for Collaboration on School Curriculum's Common Framework of Science Learning Outcomes K-12)

Space - Grade 6

  • describe the physical characteristics of components of the solar system; specifically, the sun, planets, moons, comets, asteroids, and meteors
  • describe how astronauts are able to meet their basic needs in space
  • demonstrate and explain the importance of selecting appropriate processes for investigating scientific questions and solving technological problems
  • demonstrate the importance of using the languages of science and technology to compare and communicate ideas, processes, and results
  • identify and control major variables in their investigations
  • plan a set of steps to solve a practical problem and to carry out a fair test of a science-related idea
  • compile and display data, by hand or by computer, in a variety of formats including frequency tallies, tables, and bar graphs
  • draw a conclusion, based on evidence gathered through research and observation, that answers an initial question
  • select and use tools in manipulating materials and in building models
  • record observations using a single word, notes in point form, sentences, and simple diagrams and charts
  • identify and use a variety of sources and technologies to gather pertinent information
  • communicate procedures and results, using lists, notes in point form, sentences, charts, graphs, drawings, and oral language

Thermodynamics - Grade 7

  • explain temperature using the concept of kinetic energy and the particle model of matter
  • explain how each state of matter reacts to changes in temperature
  • explain changes of state using the particle model of matter
  • compare transmission of heat by conduction, convection, and radiation
  • describe how an individual's needs can lead to developments in science and technology
  • compile and display data, by hand or computer, in a variety of formats, including diagrams, flow charts, tables, bar graphs, line graphs, and scatter plots
  • state a conclusion, based on experimental data, and explain how evidence gathered supports or refutes an initial idea
  • identify and evaluate potential applications of findings
  • select appropriate methods and tools for collecting data and information and for solving problems
  • communicate questions, ideas, intentions, plans and results, using lists, notes in point form, sentences, data tables, graphs, drawings, oral language, and other means

Background Information / Teaching Notes

The Martian Environment

The Sun on Mars

At high noon, on the Martian equator, the solar irradiance is only about 590 watts per square metre.

The Earth on the other hand receives about 1000 watts per square metre at sea level, (the atmosphere absorbing and scattering about 300 watts per square metre of the Sun's radiation before it reaches sea level).

On Mars, solar panels must be almost twice as large as solar panels on Earth to generate the same amount of electricity.

The heating effect of the noontime Sun on Mars is roughly equivalent to the heating effect of the Sun on Earth, falling on a horizontal surface at an angle of 36 degrees.

In other words, the solar irradiation at an elevation of 36 degrees, (above the horizon), on Earth is equivalent to the solar irradiation on Mars when the Sun is directly overhead.

The midsummer Sun on Mars provides much less heat than the Sun on Earth at the mid-latitudes on a very cold January day.

The Dangers of Traveling in Space and Living on Mars

The Sun is a very active star. The photosphere of the Sun, (generally known as the "surface of the Sun"), from which all the light arises, is a very hostile environment.

One of the many features seen in the photosphere are sunspots, huge magnetic storms on the Sun. Associated with sunspots are a phenomena known as solar flares.

Solar flares are first detected as huge arcs and jets of bright luminous matter erupting from the regions near sunspots. The light from a solar flare reaches interplanetary space between the Earth and Mars in 10 to 15 minutes.

Unseen, are intense beams of solar cosmic rays, (mostly protons and electrons), which are ejected by solar flares at speeds much less than the speed of light ... so they do not arrive in the interplanetary space between the Earth and Mars for a few hours and sometimes for as long as a few days after a solar flare is seen.

The frequency of solar flares follows the 11 year sunspot cycle. The frequency of solar flares is maximum when the frequency of sunspots is at a maximum.

The danger is that the sunspot/solar-flare frequency is only a statistical pattern. Solar flares can occur anytime, albeit with less probability at a sunspot minimum.

Should a large solar flare be seen during a space mission, astronauts will have only a few hours in which to take whatever actions they have available to protect themselves from the solar cosmic rays.

The radiation produced by a major flare cannot only damage or destroy electronic equipment, but it can be lethal to humans.

On Earth the atmosphere gives us an almost perfect layer of protection from solar cosmic rays, but Mars on the other hand has an atmosphere that is so thin that it provides almost no protection whatsoever.

Travelers to Mars and explorers on Mars will need to have plans in place so that they can take shelter in the event of a large solar flare.

The Sunspot Cycle

Solar activity cycle is actually a 22 year cycle even though the time from solar maximum to solar maximum is 11 years. This is because the magnetic polarity of the Sun undergoes a full reversal in 22 years.

Martian Weather and Erosion

On Mars, as with all planets, the atmosphere is (on average) in a state of thermodynamic equilibrium. That is to say, the planet's atmosphere absorbs exactly the same amount of thermal energy that it radiates into space.

In the process, the absorbed energy creates the atmospheric dynamics of wind and weather. All of this energy is eventually degraded into thermal radiation at infrared wavelengths and radiated into space.

On Earth the weather dynamics are complicated by water. Water, (as vapour), in the atmosphere and water, (as liquid), in the oceans and lakes.

When the Earth's surface becomes warm the atmosphere becomes unstable and convection begins. In the case of thunderstorms, the rising air, driven by convection, cools, but the presence of condensing water vapour releases more heat which further accelerates the convection.

This "runaway" convection, largely driven by the latent heat of condensation, gives rise to the most powerful storms on the planet ... the towering cumulonimbus clouds of violent thunderstorms.

On Mars, the absence of significant water vapour in the atmosphere, and the absence of any significant liquid water on the surface of Mars, means that the weather dynamics of Mars are somewhat simpler than on Earth.

However because the surface of Mars is exposed to direct sunlight, without clouds or water to reflect the radiation back into space, the thin atmosphere of Mars close to the surface can become much hotter than the atmosphere above it.

This very large temperature gradient in the atmosphere can produce very strong winds, capable of creating dust storms on the scale of the planet itself.

In addition to large dust storms, the surface of Mars is raked with frequent, and strong dust devils.

Luckily, at least in terms of weather, the density of the Martian atmosphere is very low, and therefore the impact of 100km/h winds on Mars is much less than similar winds would be on Earth.

Student Activity

The Earth, the Moon, and Mars, are all solid celestial objects having moderate surface gravity and soil-like surfaces. Each of these solar system objects has a unique cosmic history. To understand something about how their surfaces have changed over geological time scales this activity investigates the processes of erosion that have modified their surfaces during the past 5 billion years since their formation.

To investigate planetary erosion we will need to build three simulators, one each for the Earth, the Moon and Mars.

The diagram below illustrates the materials needed and the structure of a simple simulator. Use clean, dry sand and contour the surface to create hills and valleys and craters. Note: experience has shown that different types of sand will exhibit quite different erosion properties. You may want to try the simulation with masonry sand, (sharp and uniform), available at hardware stores, and sand from a local river or beach, (non-uniform and softer), and compare the results.

Each simulator will be placed in an environment which is somewhat similar to the real surface conditions, (as described below), and then changes in the surface will be monitored.

Planetary erosion simulator

Simulator #1: The Terrestrial Surface

Set up a simulated surface as shown.

Since this simulator is designed to study terrestrial erosion and since we are performing this simulation on the Earth's surface, this simulated surface can be placed out-of-doors exactly as you have built it without any weather protection.

Planetary erosion simulator: setup Planetary erosion simulator: Earth

Simulator #2: The Lunar Surface

Set up a simulated surface as shown.

The Lunar surface has neither wind nor rain, so this simulator must be protected from both of these weather elements. This is accomplished by placing a clear transparent weather proof shield around the simulator.

The plastic wrap not only prevents wind and rain erosion but it also helps to contribute to extreme temperature variations within the simulator, in a manner that resembles the extreme surface temperature on the Lunar surface.

Planetary erosion simulator: setup Planetary erosion simulator: Moon

Simulator #3: The Martian Surface

Set up a simulated surface as shown.

The Martian surface must also be protected from rain since there is no rain produced in the Martian weather.

There are however significant winds in the Martian atmosphere. Therefore a simple plastic "roof" over the simulator will allow wind to affect the surface, while keeping out the rain.

The plastic roof should be slightly larger than the simulated surface to prevent wind-drift from letting rain intrude into the soil.

Also, Mars is further from the Sun than the Earth. To help simulate the effect of reduced sunlight on the Martian surface the plastic is translucent, thereby reducing the intensity of sunlight.

Planetary erosion simulator: setup Planetary erosion simulator: Mars

The Simulation

Once you have set up your three simulators, it is time to set them outdoors.

Try to select a secluded area where they will not be disturbed by curious passersby or roaming animals such as cats or squirrels.

Set up a journal. Organize it so there are sections to:

  • state the purpose of the simulation
  • describe the process you used to design and build your planetary erosion simulator(s)
  • predict the outcome of the simulation
  • record your daily observations
  • make sketches and take photographs to document your observations
  • compare your observations to your predictions
  • state your final conclusions
  • record new questions that might arise from what you've observed/learned.

Leave the simulators undisturbed for several weeks, (or longer if possible). Inspect them daily and note any changes as well as the weather conditions during the previous 24 hour period in your journal.

Initial set up

Planetary erosion simulator: initial setup

After two weeks

Planetary erosion simulator: after 2 weeks

Discussion/Application

  1. Which simulated planetary surface seemed to erode the most quickly?
  2. Which simulated planetary surface seemed to erode the least quickly?
  3. Early in the history of the solar system the Earth, the Moon and Mars were heavily cratered by the impacts of material raining down on them from the debris in space that was gradually accreting into lumps that eventually became the planets and their moons.
    1. Based on your observations of the erosion patterns in your simulators, decide which of the Moon, the Earth or Mars is least likely to show evidence of heavy cratering?
    2. Which is most likely to show evidence of heavy cratering?
    3. Locate and examine photographs of Earth's surface, the Moon's surface and Mars' surface. How does the evidence provided by your erosion simulation compare with the surfaces in your photographs?

Student Assessment

R
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level 4
significantly below the standard
approaches the standard
the standard
exceeds the standard
(below 50%)
(50-59%)
(60-69%)
(70-79%)
(80-100%)

Understanding of Basic Concepts
produces insufficient evidence to demonstrate learning
demonstrates limited understanding of factors that contribute to the processes of planetary erosion
demonstrates some understanding of factors that contribute to the processes of planetary erosion
demonstrates general understanding of factors that contribute to the processes of planetary erosion
demonstrates thorough understanding of factors that contribute to the processes of planetary erosion
by providing partial explanations of the design elements of the planetary erosion simulators required to account for environmental and weather influences of the different planetary surfaces
by providing partial explanations of the design elements of the planetary erosion simulators required to account for environmental and weather influences of the different planetary surfaces
by providing complete explanations of the design elements of the planetary erosion simulators required to account for environmental and weather influences of the different planetary surfaces
by providing complete explanations of the design elements of the planetary erosion simulators required to account for environmental and weather influences of the different planetary surfaces
with significant misconceptions / inaccuracies
with minor misconceptions / inaccuracies
with no significant misconceptions / inaccuracies
with no misconceptions / inaccuracies
demonstrates significant misconceptions
Application of Critical and Creative Thinking Skills and/or Processes
applies appropriate skills/strategies to design and construct planetary erosion simulators, set up a simulation journal, and make and record observations with limited effectiveness
applies appropriate skills/strategies to design and construct planetary erosion simulators, set up a simulation journal, and make and record observations with some effectiveness
applies appropriate skills/strategies to design and construct planetary erosion simulators, set up a simulation journal, and make and record observations with considerable effectiveness
applies appropriate skills/strategies to design and construct planetary erosion simulators, set up a simulation journal, and make and record observations with a high degree of effectiveness
requires additional learning activities and remediation
Communication of Required Knowledge
organizes and expresses ideas and information with limited effectiveness
organizes and expresses ideas and information with some effectiveness
organizes and expresses ideas and information with considerable effectiveness
organizes and expresses ideas and information with a high degree of effectiveness
rarely using appropriate scientific conventions, vocabulary, and terminology
sometimes using appropriate scientific conventions, vocabulary, and terminology
usually using appropriate scientific conventions, vocabulary, and terminology
consistently using appropriate scientific conventions, vocabulary, and terminology
Application of Required Knowledge
refers to observations made during the planetary erosion simulation, to inform identification and description of key features in images of the surfaces of the Moon, the Earth and Mars making very simple connections
refers to observations made during the planetary erosion simulation, to inform identification and description of key features in images of the surfaces of the Moon, the Earth and Mars making simple connections
refers to observations made during the planetary erosion simulation, to inform identification and description of key features in images of the surfaces of the Moon, the Earth and Mars making connections of some complexity
refers to observations made during the planetary erosion simulation, to inform identification and description of key features in images of the surfaces of the Moon, the Earth and Mars making complex connections